Go Ahead. Click the spreadsheets first.
The “Ever-Expanding Universe of Vouchers” was a blog post https://treetn.org/expanding-vouche… TREE did last year warning Tennessee about school voucher intentions. In that blog we stated, “Voucher supporters, along with money from outside interests, will stop at nothing to expand voucher programs in Tennessee, effectively creating a privatized black hole for taxpayer dollars. Tennessee ranks 47th in funding for public education, leaving schools to tread water while legislators look for ways to fund private schools.” And where are we AGAIN this year? Fighting back multiple attempts to expand public school vouchers.
One bill will expand the TN IEP voucher. Only 38 out of 20k qualifying families bothered to sign up for the current version of this voucher. But, it is not about what families want. It is about expanding. This new version wants to qualify more disabilities to wave their IDEA rights and take the money even though we have no idea if the pilot works. This IEP expansion is modeled after Arizona. The Arizona Legislature created its ESA program in 2011 for special-needs students and has since expanded it to allow children from poor-performing schools, from military families, and others. Watch for this pattern in Tennessee. It is all intentional.
MEMPHIS IS THE TARGET
The other voucher bill (HB126) left progressing through committee is squarely and unfairly aimed at Memphis as a pilot. And Memphis parents, school boards, and elected officials have not been silent in their objection. Here is what we know about urban pilots. Every time a voucher starts as an urban pilot for a small number of students, it expands across the state. Flashback to charter schools as an urban pilot solution. And now several rural districts are seeing charter school intent letters. The playbook is followed in every state where privatized solutions proliferate. Vouchers will not stop at a pilot. Isn’t the point of a pilot to see if something works? The word pilot is a sham. We don’t even know if the IEP disability pilot is working and it is already expanding.
This Memphis pilot bill is stuck on whether it will even use the TNReady to see if the pilot works. How is that fair? How do you show a voucher pilot improves educational outcomes for children if they don’t take TNReady?
THANK YOU COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
Concerns are growing fast as the County Commissioners Association published a spreadsheet (shown above) that TREE obtained via email, sent to Association members outlining a rough idea, county by county illustrating “[H]ow a k-12 voucher program might impact county budgets, particularly if you compare revenue lost when a student transfers out of a school district and into a private school. https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B6… ) The chart shows the amount of county property tax needed to offset a 10-percent decrease in student population. [The Association] research has cross-checked many of the systems and, for the most part, it appears to be accurate. ” Of note: Carroll County sets its districts differently, so the formula used does not translate for that county.
The property tax increases to offset vouchers seen on the spreadsheet is not something any county commissioner wants to pass on to property owners. Lauderdale County loses the most with an 84.23 cent increase per year. Davidson is looking at a 30.36 cent increase. The Tennessee Ed Report did a post that outlined skyrocketing taxes in Indiana and some potential scenarios for Tennessee. http://tnedreport.com/2017/03/the-v…
School vouchers become a parallel school system to fund. One Tennessee cannot afford.
Parents feel vouchers are an empty promise. Study after study show they do not work to increase achievement. https://www.brookings.edu/research/… Without transportation and the ability to cover all the extras, a voucher is not really in reach of most public school families. The private schools most familiar won’t be taking vouchers. And in the end, voucher school choice is the choice of the private school to accept a student and to keep a student. It opens the door to discriminatory practices that leave Shelby County parents in doubt this is little more than a religious school subsidy with tax dollars that experiments on their children.
Our government needs to invest in neighborhood schools, invest in RTi2 small intervention classes, time with a teacher, community schools coordinators to coordinate wrap-around services and discipline supports. Fund opportunities to engage in learning. Not siphon off public dollars into private, unregulated hands. We must support Shelby County Schools, not public money for vouchers. Former Lt. Governor Ron Ramsey confirmed that he supported intentions to expand the program statewide when he recently spoke to a group of Shelby County Republicans in Bartlett. These pilots are nothing more than seeds for state voucher program growth and higher taxes.
Please CALL AND write the Finance Sub-Committee. Ask them to vote NO on school vouchers. Thank them for their service and especially thank them if they are a NO vote. The Memphis pilot voucher bill will be heard in finance subcommittee next. Please tell them not to fall for this scheme to destroy our public school system and raise our property taxes.
House Finance Subcommittee 2017:
Rep. Kevin Brooks (R-Cleveland): 615/741-1350 firstname.lastname@example.org
Rep. Karen Camper (D-Memphis): 615/741-1898 email@example.com
Rep. Jim Coley (R-Bartlett): 615/741-8201 firstname.lastname@example.org
Rep. Craig Fitzhugh (D-Ripley): 615/741-2134 email@example.com
Rep. David Hawk (R-Greeneville): 615/741-7482 firstname.lastname@example.org
Rep. Patsy Hazlewood (R-Signal Mountain): 615/741-2746 email@example.com
Rep. Gary Hicks (R-Rogersville): 615/741-7480 firstname.lastname@example.org
Rep. Harold M. Love, Jr. (D-Nashville): 615/741-3831 email@example.com
Rep. Gerald McCormick (R-Chattanooga): 615/741-2548 firstname.lastname@example.org
Rep. Steve McDaniel (R-Parkers Crossroads): 615/741-0750 email@example.com
Rep. Charles Sargent (R-Franklin): 615/741-6808 firstname.lastname@example.org
Rep. Ryan Williams (R-Cookeville): 615/741-1875 email@example.com